25 Apr 2024, 02:31 [ UTC - 5; DST ]
|
Username Protected |
Message |
Username Protected
|
Post subject: Re: Cirrus to offer FIKI on its new planes Posted: 09 Jan 2009, 10:05 |
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: 11/27/07 Posts: 4290 Post Likes: +1434 Company: BeechTalk Location: Pontiac, MI (KPTK)
Aircraft: 1991 Bonanza A36
|
|
Username Protected wrote: If the FAA certifies it using the same process as any other FIKI-certified airplane, why would it be any more dangerous? How much Cirrus time do you have (including time accumulating ice, etc)?
-Neal It has nothing to do with Cirrus vs anything. It has to do with the sensibility of flying a piston engine airplane into ice. Yes, if your airplane is FIKI you can legally fly into icing conditions. However some think...at least I think...that ice needs a turbine. You just don't have the same capabilities in a piston airplane. Now, if you want to be specific toward a Cirrus, I am interested how they are going to deal with those big ice catchers hanging down under the airplane. Jim Jim -
Thanks for typing that. That is exactly my thoughts.
Neal, on the scale of ice-tolerant planes, a single engine piston is on the bottom of my favorites list. That would include Cessnas, Beeches, Mooneys, and Cirri. The twin piston FIKI, for me, are a tad bit better, but still a stretch.
My position has changed a bit on this topic over the years, but I find myself gravitating to the old adage that pistons and ice don't mix. It's one thing to have equipment to stack the deck in your favor to get you out of unforecasted ice, but it's another thing to rely on that equipment to launch into forecasted ice. For me, FIKI is really more for legality than performance (at least to some extent).
And, by the way, to answer your question, I have only 20-30 hours of Cirrus time. I have no Cirrus time accumulating ice.
_________________ CFI/CFII/MEI
|
|
Top |
|
Username Protected
|
Post subject: Re: Cirrus to offer FIKI on its new planes Posted: 09 Jan 2009, 13:01 |
|
|
|
|
Joined: 10/03/08 Posts: 3288 Post Likes: +1230 Location: HPN/NY
Aircraft: T210M
|
|
Username Protected wrote: I just spoke with one of my friends who works at Cirrus. They have received FIKI certification for their new SR22's. Pretty cool stuff. Supposedly there was a lot of changes to their TKS system in order to make it happen. Announcement to come out officially on Monday.
-Neal Neal -- I hope that one of the changes is to about double the fluid capacity of the system.
|
|
Top |
|
Username Protected
|
Post subject: Re: Cirrus to offer FIKI on its new planes Posted: 09 Jan 2009, 13:36 |
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: 06/25/08 Posts: 5648 Post Likes: +519 Company: Latitude Aviation Location: Los Angeles, CA (KTOA)
Aircraft: 2007 Bonanza G36
|
|
Username Protected wrote: Neal -- I hope that one of the changes is to about double the fluid capacity of the system. Just spoke to my friend - doubled to 8 gallons with a minimum of 5 for dispatch. -Neal
_________________ Latitude Aviation Specializing in sales/acquisitions services for Bonanzas, Barons, and TBM's
|
|
Top |
|
Username Protected
|
Post subject: Re: Cirrus to offer FIKI on its new planes Posted: 09 Jan 2009, 14:06 |
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: 11/27/07 Posts: 4290 Post Likes: +1434 Company: BeechTalk Location: Pontiac, MI (KPTK)
Aircraft: 1991 Bonanza A36
|
|
Username Protected wrote: I originally thought that Jeff was making a slam towards the Cirrus product. I guess I get a little put off on here sometimes when I see anti-Cirrus posts with little qualitative or quantitative evidence for back-up. Hey Neal, just for the record, I like Cirri (or Cirruseses). Don't tell anyone, but a few months ago, I strongly considered getting in to the Cirrus AirShares program. I have nothing again Cirrus and appreciate their presence in the marketplace--it has certainly forced other manufactures (especially Cessna and some of the other upstarts) to refocus. That is great for all of us. They are one of the few manufacturers still pushing for new products, new certifications, etc. As I mentioned above, I think having the FIKI certification will certainly help them attract new buyers. But, like I mentioned above, I am getting more and more nervous about dealing with ice in a piston plane. Our Baron is de-iced, which in a way is a good thing--it's an extra tool to help me get out of unforecasted icing, but doesn't give me any false hope to launch into it. My comments are really just personal risk level thresholds and not a commentary on Cirrus' product line/quality.
_________________ CFI/CFII/MEI
|
|
Top |
|
Username Protected
|
Post subject: Re: Cirrus to offer FIKI on its new planes Posted: 09 Jan 2009, 14:27 |
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: 06/25/08 Posts: 5648 Post Likes: +519 Company: Latitude Aviation Location: Los Angeles, CA (KTOA)
Aircraft: 2007 Bonanza G36
|
|
Username Protected wrote: Hey Neal, just for the record, I like Cirri (or Cirruseses). Don't tell anyone, but a few months ago, I strongly considered getting in to the Cirrus AirShares program. I have nothing again Cirrus and appreciate their presence in the marketplace--it has certainly forced other manufactures (especially Cessna and some of the other upstarts) to refocus. That is great for all of us. They are one of the few manufacturers still pushing for new products, new certifications, etc.
As I mentioned above, I think having the FIKI certification will certainly help them attract new buyers. But, like I mentioned above, I am getting more and more nervous about dealing with ice in a piston plane. Our Baron is de-iced, which in a way is a good thing--it's an extra tool to help me get out of unforecasted icing, but doesn't give me any false hope to launch into it.
My comments are really just personal risk level thresholds and not a commentary on Cirrus' product line/quality. Thank you for the clarification and I agree with you on all of your points (I generally do agree with your posts). You and I have the same approach to ice in pistons. I am just glad that the only ice I really deal with is in equipment that can handle it. We are overly paranoid about the stuff frankly. -Neal
_________________ Latitude Aviation Specializing in sales/acquisitions services for Bonanzas, Barons, and TBM's
|
|
Top |
|
Username Protected
|
Post subject: Re: Cirrus to offer FIKI on its new planes Posted: 09 Jan 2009, 15:36 |
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: 08/11/08 Posts: 1437 Post Likes: +311 Location: KAAF Apalachicola, Fl
Aircraft: CCSS: N3YC
|
|
Username Protected wrote: Hey Neal, just for the record, I like Cirri (or Cirruseses). Don't tell anyone, but a few months ago, I strongly considered getting in to the Cirrus AirShares program. I have nothing again Cirrus and appreciate their presence in the marketplace--it has certainly forced other manufactures (especially Cessna and some of the other upstarts) to refocus. That is great for all of us. They are one of the few manufacturers still pushing for new products, new certifications, etc.
As I mentioned above, I think having the FIKI certification will certainly help them attract new buyers. But, like I mentioned above, I am getting more and more nervous about dealing with ice in a piston plane. Our Baron is de-iced, which in a way is a good thing--it's an extra tool to help me get out of unforecasted icing, but doesn't give me any false hope to launch into it.
My comments are really just personal risk level thresholds and not a commentary on Cirrus' product line/quality. Thank you for the clarification and I agree with you on all of your points (I generally do agree with your posts). You and I have the same approach to ice in pistons. I am just glad that the only ice I really deal with is in equipment that can handle it. We are overly paranoid about the stuff frankly. -Neal
Neal: just to add to the love-fest I too was seduced heavily by the Cirrus product. I took a good hard look at a TN SR 22 G3 when I was getting ready to spend the big bucks on my F 33. And I'm telling you, the level of fit and finish and the air conditioning was enough to tip me and SWMBO over the top and drop the big bux on one. We got in with the demo pilot and (middle of the summer...was 90 and Alabama humid) sitting in there with the AC running, comfortable as hell...and now, remember, just me, wifey and the demo guy who couldn't have weighed more'n 150 or so...we blasted off and the demo guy said: "It's climbing a little sluggishly because, since we nearly have full fuel, we're over gross..."
! Huh?! I further pushed on him and he said, and I swear this is true: "Well, sometimes you just need to make a mistake in the calculations..." Well, we finished the flight, and the airplane is lovely and all, but I can put full fuel, me, 3 other 200 pounders and 100 pounds of luggage and full fuel in my Deb (goodness I do love my TAT turbo and its gross-up)...and I couldn't carry more than my wife, me and luggage with full fuel in the Cirrus. I admit that we're talking AC and weeping wings (neither of which I have in the Deb, and both of which add significant weight), but that was a deal killer.
And of course the attitude demonstrated by the demo guy may have something to do with the Cirrus culture of being a bit less risk-adverse than I am. I met the guy who porpoised on landing, curled his prop blades, and just "straightened out the blades" on his prop (using a channel-lock, I think)...and flew home.
So one wonders what some of these (and I stress...some of these...) Cirrus drivers are gonna do with a fresh FIKI certification in hand. It makes one wonder what's that gonna do to our insurance.
Edit: And that's from a doctor that flys a bonanza!
Jim
_________________ Jim Harper Montgomery, AL and Apalachicola, FL
|
|
Top |
|
Username Protected
|
Post subject: Re: Cirrus to offer FIKI on its new planes Posted: 09 Jan 2009, 16:33 |
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: 06/25/08 Posts: 5648 Post Likes: +519 Company: Latitude Aviation Location: Los Angeles, CA (KTOA)
Aircraft: 2007 Bonanza G36
|
|
Username Protected wrote: Neal: just to add to the love-fest I too was seduced heavily by the Cirrus product. I took a good hard look at a TN SR 22 G3 when I was getting ready to spend the big bucks on my F 33. And I'm telling you, the level of fit and finish and the air conditioning was enough to tip me and SWMBO over the top and drop the big bux on one. We got in with the demo pilot and (middle of the summer...was 90 and Alabama humid) sitting in there with the AC running, comfortable as hell...and now, remember, just me, wifey and the demo guy who couldn't have weighed more'n 150 or so...we blasted off and the demo guy said: "It's climbing a little sluggishly because, since we nearly have full fuel, we're over gross..." ! Huh?! I further pushed on him and he said, and I swear this is true: "Well, sometimes you just need to make a mistake in the calculations..." Well, we finished the flight, and the airplane is lovely and all, but I can put full fuel, me, 3 other 200 pounders and 100 pounds of luggage and full fuel in my Deb (goodness I do love my TAT turbo and its gross-up)...and I couldn't carry more than my wife, me and luggage with full fuel in the Cirrus. I admit that we're talking AC and weeping wings (neither of which I have in the Deb, and both of which add significant weight), but that was a deal killer. And of course the attitude demonstrated by the demo guy may have something to do with the Cirrus culture of being a bit less risk-adverse than I am. I met the guy who porpoised on landing, curled his prop blades, and just "straightened out the blades" on his prop (using a channel-lock, I think)...and flew home. So one wonders what some of these (and I stress... some of these...) Cirrus drivers are gonna do with a fresh FIKI certification in hand. It makes one wonder what's that gonna do to our insurance. Edit: And that's from a doctor that flys a bonanza! Jim Jim, That's an odd story. Do you remember who it was that took you flying? His behavior and professionalism is suspect obviously and very unlike the attitudes of the many Cirrus employees I've met. Sadly, they do have one blemish on their record when their NorCal sales guy augered in last year doing low level maneuvers that he shouldn't have been doing. I'm going to de-identify your story if its okay and send it to my friend at Cirrus, who is fairly high up the food chain (reports directly to the CEO) because if that is how their demo pilots are handling their flights, then they need a swift change of attitude in a fast way. I'm not even sure his numbers are correct frankly. I'll let you know. -Neal
_________________ Latitude Aviation Specializing in sales/acquisitions services for Bonanzas, Barons, and TBM's
|
|
Top |
|
Username Protected
|
Post subject: Re: Cirrus to offer FIKI on its new planes Posted: 09 Jan 2009, 16:54 |
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: 01/07/08 Posts: 2828 Post Likes: +434 Location: Walnut Creek, CA (KCCR)
Aircraft: 1979 Baron 58P
|
|
Username Protected wrote: And of course the attitude demonstrated by the demo guy may have something to do with the Cirrus culture of being a bit less risk-adverse than I am. I met the guy who porpoised on landing, curled his prop blades, and just "straightened out the blades" on his prop (using a channel-lock, I think)...and flew home.
Jim I saw an SR-22 with badly curled blades at the airport where I am based. I asked a mechanic who was working on it what had happened. The pilot had porpoised at an airport about 50 miles away and curled the blades. After examining the damage, he got back in and flew home with the bent prop.
|
|
Top |
|
Username Protected
|
Post subject: Re: Cirrus to offer FIKI on its new planes Posted: 09 Jan 2009, 17:19 |
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: 08/11/08 Posts: 1437 Post Likes: +311 Location: KAAF Apalachicola, Fl
Aircraft: CCSS: N3YC
|
|
Username Protected wrote: That's an odd story. Do you remember who it was that took you flying? His behavior and professionalism is suspect obviously and very unlike the attitudes of the many Cirrus employees I've met. Sadly, they do have one blemish on their record when their NorCal sales guy augered in last year doing low level maneuvers that he shouldn't have been doing. I'm going to de-identify your story if its okay and send it to my friend at Cirrus, who is fairly high up the food chain (reports directly to the CEO) because if that is how their demo pilots are handling their flights, then they need a swift change of attitude in a fast way. I'm not even sure his numbers are correct frankly. I'll let you know.
-Neal Feel free to identify me. Drop me a PM and I'll send you my contact stuff if you so desire. I don't remember the guy's name, but I do remember where and when, and I suspect they can reconstruct it. I am pretty comfortable with the accuracy of his numbers. Looking at the Cirrus site, the useful load of an AC'd Cirrus is 935 pounds...a Bo's worth of fuel leaves us with 491 pounds. In the terminology of one of my favorite comics, I am a big old boy, and I would only leave 215 pounds worth of load to carry. Add TKS fluid and my 150 pound wife...You do the math. My Deb has a useful load of 1372 pounds. Add fuel and me and I still can carry another 653 pounds. It was a no-brainer. Although that AC surely was nice! Jim
_________________ Jim Harper Montgomery, AL and Apalachicola, FL
|
|
Top |
|
Username Protected
|
Post subject: Re: Cirrus to offer FIKI on its new planes Posted: 09 Jan 2009, 18:22 |
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: 12/18/07 Posts: 20047 Post Likes: +8496 Location: Chicago
Aircraft: Ex PA22, P28R, V35B
|
|
Username Protected wrote: Although that AC surely was nice!
Jim
For the money you saved by not buying the Cirrus, you could install A/C in your Deb? I thought somebody had an aftermarket STC for 25 AMU or so.
_________________ Falsehood flies, and truth comes limping after it. (J. Swift)
|
|
Top |
|
Username Protected
|
Post subject: Re: Cirrus to offer FIKI on its new planes Posted: 09 Jan 2009, 19:11 |
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: 08/15/08 Posts: 1075 Post Likes: +38 Location: Santa Rosa, CA (KSTS)
Aircraft: 1975 Bonanza A36
|
|
Username Protected wrote: Just to tack onto this thread, and while talking about highly-skilled pilots making errors in judgement, we watched another company test pilot crash and die only five minutes after he said that his plane was designed so that it was impossible for it to stall.
Yuk, I didn't need that - I know too many people I have respected who are no longer here due to screw ups or in some cases just plain bad luck. "But for the grace of God...." But, I guess, thanks for the reminder - keep it real, keep it humble, keep it blue side up.
Last edited on 09 Jan 2009, 19:48, edited 1 time in total.
|
|
Top |
|
Username Protected
|
Post subject: Re: Cirrus to offer FIKI on its new planes Posted: 09 Jan 2009, 19:42 |
|
|
|
|
|
Joined: 06/25/08 Posts: 5648 Post Likes: +519 Company: Latitude Aviation Location: Los Angeles, CA (KTOA)
Aircraft: 2007 Bonanza G36
|
|
Username Protected wrote: Regarding the Cirrus rep who augered in . . .
I had flown with him several times. Flew formation with him, from the photo plane, and also sitting right seat in the Cirrus.
He checked me out in the Cirrus.
Very much a hot dog. Heck of a good stick. I interviewed him on the first shoot for WTA.
As many, many pilots have shown, though, being a good stick doesn't trump bad judgement.
You can not beat the world record for low level flight. You can only tie.
Thom was a lot of fun, though. I sure hated that he died that way. Yes, I've met Thom as well. He reported directly to my friend. Very sad (but avoidable) story. My friend told me of a video shoots and photo shoots and Thom was always the one who got them. Small world that you were involved. My friend said the same thing you did....good stick, bad judgement, good guy. Sad story. But another classic example of "The Rogue Aviator" as defined by Tony Kern in his books/studies. -Neal
_________________ Latitude Aviation Specializing in sales/acquisitions services for Bonanzas, Barons, and TBM's
|
|
Top |
|
|
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot post attachments in this forum
|
Terms of Service | Forum FAQ | Contact Us
BeechTalk, LLC is the quintessential Beechcraft Owners & Pilots Group providing a
forum for the discussion of technical, practical, and entertaining issues relating to all Beech aircraft. These include
the Bonanza (both V-tail and straight-tail models), Baron, Debonair, Duke, Twin Bonanza, King Air, Sierra, Skipper, Sport, Sundowner,
Musketeer, Travel Air, Starship, Queen Air, BeechJet, and Premier lines of airplanes, turboprops, and turbojets.
BeechTalk, LLC is not affiliated or endorsed by the Beechcraft Corporation, its subsidiaries, or affiliates.
Beechcraft™, King Air™, and Travel Air™ are the registered trademarks of the Beechcraft Corporation.
Copyright© BeechTalk, LLC 2007-2024
|
|
|
|